Preprint reviews by Paul Carini

Ecological selection for small microbial genomes along a temperate-to-thermal soil gradient

Sourced from

Jackson W Sorensen, Taylor K Dunivin, Tammy C Tobin, Ashley Shade

Review posted on 05th March 2018

This is a really neat paper! I quickly read it and offer a few suggestions to make the next revision a bit tighter.

1. Throughout the paper, be sure not to conflate "small genomes" with genom...

See full review here.

Relic DNA contributes minimally to estimates of microbial diversity

Sourced from

Jay T Lennon, Sarah A Placella, Mario E Muscarella

Review posted on 01st May 2017

The main broad conclusion of this work (“relic DNA contributes minimally to the characterization of microbial community structure”) is not well-supported by the data presented.


See full review here.